“But I tell you that smoke is more important than the pig, however often you kill one.”
RalphChapter 5
Civilisation vs SavageryLoss of Innocence
Context: Ralph insists to the boys that the signal fire — the smoke that could bring rescue — matters far more than Jack's hunting.
Analysis
The blunt comparative "more important than the pig" elevates the signal fire into a symbol of the boys' hope of returning to civilisation, set against the hunters' immediate appetite for meat. Ralph alone keeps the long-term goal of rescue in focus, distinguishing his reason from Jack's instinct. The fading smoke later mirrors the dwindling order on the island.
Language Techniques:
SymbolismJuxtapositionDirect address
Exam Tip
Use the signal fire as a symbol of hope and civilisation throughout. Ralph's obsession with the fire contrasts with the hunters' obsession with meat and blood.